The Statler Brothers, renowned for their harmonious blend and storytelling prowess, crafted a poignant narrative in their song “Susan When She Tried.” Released as part of their 1975 album “The Best of The Statler Brothers,” this song stands out not just for its melodic charm but also for the rich story it weaves, encapsulating a blend of admiration and wistful reflection.
At its core, “Susan When She Tried” is a tribute to the enchanting impact of a woman named Susan on the narrator’s life. It’s a lyrical ode that captures the essence of youthful love and its enduring memory. The song is beautifully structured to convey a sense of nostalgia, mixed with a bit of heartache, as the narrator recounts the vivid details of his encounters with Susan. The charm of the song lies in its ability to transport listeners to that moment in time, making them feel the sweetness and the sorrow of the memories being sung.
What makes this song resonate with so many is its universal theme of cherished, yet bygone relationships. It’s not just about the person of Susan but about all such relationships that leave a lasting imprint on our lives. The emotional depth of the song, coupled with the Statler Brothers’ harmonious delivery, stirs a sense of connection that goes beyond the lyrics, reaching into the shared experiences of its audience.
This track also showcases the Statler Brothers’ skill in blending country rhythms with pop elements, making it not only a lyrical piece but also a melodious treat that appeals to a wide range of listeners. Its success is a testament to their ability to craft songs that are both personal and profoundly relatable
Video
Lyrics
I got over Charlotte Thompson, Goldie Johnson,
Lord they done me wrong
I took it hard with Peggy Harper
She hurt me bad, but not for long
There’s just one I remember
Makes me feel funny down inside
I’d trade ’em all for just one hour
Of Susan when she tried
No there’s never been a woman
Who could make me weak inside
And give me what I needed
Like Susan when she tried
It gets worse in the summer
When the nights are hot and long
And it’s bad in December
When they play those Christmas songs
So if you ask me and I don’t tell you
Bet your sweet bottom dollar I lied
Cause there’s never been one better
Than Susan when she tried